Marketplace comparison · US / USD
ThredUp vs Poshmark 2026: Which Is Better for Selling?
ThredUp and Poshmark both resell secondhand clothing, but they are different kinds of service. ThredUp is managed consignment: you mail a bag and it lists and ships the items for a share of each sale. Poshmark is a marketplace: you list, price and ship every item yourself and keep most of the money. The choice is your time against your payout.
Sources checked By Akasha Ahmed, ResaleMargin
Calculate a Poshmark payoutQuick answer
Poshmark is better if you want the most money and can do the work: you keep 80% of a sale of $15 or more. ThredUp is better if you want the clothes gone with very little work: you mail a bag and it pays a share that rises with the selling price, from 3% at $5 to 80% at $200 in its published examples, less a $14.99 service fee on a Standard bag. A $50 sale pays $40.00 on Poshmark and $15.00 in ThredUp's example.
ThredUp vs Poshmark at a glance
| ThredUp Clean Out | Poshmark | |
|---|---|---|
| Type of service | Managed consignment: you send a bag | Marketplace: you sell each item yourself |
| Who lists and ships | ThredUp | You |
| Who sets the price | ThredUp; you can edit within limits | You |
| What you earn | A share of the selling price that rises with price | 80% on $15 or more; the price minus $2.95 under $15 |
| Other seller fees | Service fee $14.99 Standard or $34.99 Premium, taken from earnings | None to list |
| Accepts | Women’s and kids’ clothing, handbags, shoes, accessories | Women’s, kids’ and men’s fashion, plus select other categories |
| Time limit to sell | 30–45 days Standard; 60–90 days Premium | No consignment window |
| Buyer returns | 14 days, handled by ThredUp | All sales final; 72 hours to report a problem |
| When you are paid | After the 14-day return window | On buyer acceptance, or 3 days after delivery |
| Unsold items | Reclaim for a fee, or they become ThredUp’s | Stay with you |
How each one works, step by step
ThredUp calls its seller service a Clean Out. Its Help Center sums up its side of the deal this way: it provides the prepaid label or bag, then processes, lists, stores and ships the items to its buyers. There are three versions: Standard, Premium, and Donation, where ThredUp gives $5 per bag to a charity you choose and you receive no payout.
- Order a kit. A kit is either a 30 lb bag or a printable label for your own box. The bag costs $2.99 on Standard and is free on Premium; labels are free. A kit expires within 3 months of being requested. Clean Outs are offered only in the 48 contiguous states.
- Fill it and send it. Up to 30 lbs ships free from any UPS drop-off location. A paid courier pick-up is also available.
- ThredUp processes the bag. It decides which items to list. Its guide says it accepts an average of 60–80% of items in Standard Clean Outs and 80–90% in Premium ones (figures as shown on November 12, 2026).
- ThredUp prices and lists. Each accepted item gets a consignment window, which is the period it has to sell for you to earn on it.
- An item sells. ThredUp ships it. You earn a percentage of the selling price as ThredUp credit once the buyer's return window closes.
- An item doesn't sell. You can pay to get it back near the end of its window, or leave it with ThredUp.
Poshmark gives you the tools and the buyers, and you do the rest.
- List each item. A listing takes up to 16 photos and a title of up to 80 characters. Listing is free.
- Set the price and handle offers. Buyers can negotiate privately through Make an Offer. An offer you accept is binding.
- Ship when it sells. Poshmark sends one prepaid label or QR code per order. You pack the item and hand it to USPS.
- Get paid. Earnings are released when the buyer accepts the order, or automatically 3 days after delivery.
ThredUp is also testing a marketplace-style option called Direct Listings, where you keep items at home, set your own prices and ship to buyers. It is in beta and separate from Clean Out, so the rest of this guide compares Clean Out with Poshmark.
What each accepts and rejects
ThredUp's Clean Out Guide asks for gently used women's and kids' clothing, handbags, shoes and accessories. Items must be clean, in good condition, unaltered and carry a size label. Its category list adds maternity and plus-size clothing, swimwear, formal and bridesmaid dresses, watches other than smartwatches, and bags from wallets to backpacks.
| Rule | What ThredUp says |
|---|---|
| Not accepted: categories | Men’s clothing and accessories; undergarments, slips, PJs, slippers and robes; wedding dresses and ballgowns; work uniforms and adult costumes |
| Not accepted: item types | Tailored, homemade or altered items; items without size tags, except luxury brands and Lululemon; promotional “free with purchase” items; graphics referencing local teams or places |
| Not accepted: non-clothing | Jewelry except watches; phone and tablet cases; hair accessories; toys, books and sports gear |
| Condition | No rips, tears, pilling, fading, shrinkage or blemishes of any kind |
| New with tags | Not listed automatically; the item must still meet the quality standard |
| Brands | All brands accepted; about 5% of brands earn no payout unless the item sells for $20 or more |
| No brand label | Women’s items are priced lower; kids’ items must have a brand tag |
| Sets | Matching sets are not listed together |
The condition rule comes from ThredUp's acceptance standards. What happens to an item that fails depends on the service. In a Standard Clean Out, unlisted items are reused or recycled and you don't get them back. In a Premium Clean Out they are returned to you by default. Items from no-payout brands that aren't accepted are not eligible to be returned.
Poshmark describes itself as a marketplace for women's, kids' and men's fashion and accessories, new personal care products, select home goods, select pet items and select electronics. Among its rules: used socks and underwear are not allowed, while pre-owned bras and swimwear are; makeup must be new; replicas are banned. You describe the condition yourself, and the buyer can open a case if the item isn't as described.
The biggest practical gap is men's clothing, which ThredUp turns away and Poshmark accepts.
What you earn on the same selling price
| Selling price | ThredUp example | Poshmark payout | Poshmark pays more by |
|---|---|---|---|
| $5.00 | 3% → $0.15 | $2.05 | $1.90 |
| $20.00 | 15% → $3.00 | $16.00 | $13.00 |
| $50.00 | 30% → $15.00 | $40.00 | $25.00 |
| $100.00 | 60% → $60.00 | $80.00 | $20.00 |
| $200.00 | 80% → $160.00 | $160.00 | $0.00 |
The ThredUp column repeats the five examples in its Clean Out Guide; the guide gives no rate for prices in between, so this page doesn't either. The Poshmark column comes from this site's calculator, using the Fee Policy: a flat $2.95 on sales under $15 and 20% on sales of $15 or more. How much Poshmark takes covers that fee in detail.
One assumption sits under the table: that an item sells for the same price on both. On Poshmark you choose the price. On ThredUp the price is set for you and tends to fall over time, as the pricing section below explains.
Where ThredUp's share catches up with Poshmark's
| Selling price | ThredUp share | Poshmark share | ThredUp after $14.99 fee | Poshmark payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5.00 | 3% | 41% | $0.00 | $2.05 |
| $20.00 | 15% | 80% | $0.00 | $16.00 |
| $50.00 | 30% | 80% | $0.01 | $40.00 |
| $100.00 | 60% | 80% | $45.01 | $80.00 |
| $200.00 | 80% | 80% | $145.01 | $160.00 |
Among the published examples, ThredUp's share reaches Poshmark's only at $200, where both pay $160.00 before the service fee. At $100 ThredUp pays $60.00 and Poshmark $80.00. Once the service fee is counted, a single $200 sale leaves $145.01 from a Standard bag or $125.01 from a Premium one. So even at ThredUp's best published rate, Poshmark pays at least as much.
What the service fee does to a small bag
ThredUp's fee page sets the service fee at $14.99 for Standard and $34.99 for Premium. It is deducted from your earnings only after items sell, and if you earn less than the fee, you aren't charged the difference. The fee is the same whether one item sells or twenty, so it weighs most on a small or low-priced bag.
| Items sold | ThredUp earnings | After $14.99 service fee | Poshmark payout |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 sold at $20.00 each | $9.00 | $0.00 | $48.00 |
| 5 sold at $20.00 each | $15.00 | $0.01 | $80.00 |
| 10 sold at $20.00 each | $30.00 | $15.01 | $160.00 |
| 5 sold at $50.00 each | $75.00 | $60.01 | $200.00 |
| 2 sold at $100.00 each | $120.00 | $105.01 | $160.00 |
| 1 sold at $200.00 each | $160.00 | $145.01 | $160.00 |
At ThredUp's $20 example rate, it takes 5 sales just to cover the Standard fee. These examples are generous to ThredUp, because they assume everything sells. ThredUp's guide, as shown on November 12, 2026, says about 38% of accepted items don't sell within their consignment window.
On that date the guide also showed an offer for new sellers: a $0 service fee and no bag fee on up to 2 Standard bags or labels that ThredUp receives within 30 days of ordering. ThredUp marks the offer as subject to change.
Poshmark has costs of its own that the tables leave out. The buyer normally pays for the label, but an Offer to Likers usually carries a shipping discount that is deducted from your earnings. Enter your own numbers in the Poshmark fee calculator.
Who controls the price
On ThredUp, the company does, with some room for you. Its guide says: “We price your items. Our algorithms set prices based on past sales, brand, and item quality.” You can then edit the price. On a Standard Clean Out you can raise it by up to 10%; on a Premium Clean Out, by up to 80%. On both you can lower it to as little as $4.99. Edits are allowed any time before the item is added to a buyer's cart.
ThredUp also moves the price without you. It gradually lowers prices over time and offers discounts to buyers, and it says both can reduce your payout. For Premium Clean Outs the effect of buyer discounts on your earnings is capped at 20%. Its payout article adds that when an item is bought with a discount or promo code, the sale price falls and the payout percentage falls with it. Your earnings are worked out on the final selling price, not the first listed price.
On Poshmark every price decision is yours. You set the list price and decide which offers to accept. Poshmark's tools reward price cuts: a Price Drop of at least 10% notifies the people who liked the listing, and an Offer to Likers must be at least 10% below the current price. You decide whether to use them. Discounts for buyers who take several items are covered in Poshmark bundles.
Our inference: price control matters most on higher-value pieces, where ThredUp's share is highest but a falling price also costs the most dollars.
How long it takes
| Step | Standard Clean Out | Premium Clean Out |
|---|---|---|
| Bag arrives after ordering | About a week | About a week |
| Processing | 21–28 days | 14 days |
| Listing | Most items within a day, the rest within 15 days | Most items within a day, the rest within 15 days |
| Consignment window, lower-end brands | 30 days | 60 days |
| Consignment window, higher-end brands | 45 days | 90 days |
| Buyer return window before credit is issued | 14 days | 14 days |
| Bag order to final earnings, most Clean Outs | 10–14 weeks | 16–20 weeks |
ThredUp notes that earnings trickle in before the end as individual items sell. The fixed parts of the wait are processing and the 14-day return window after each sale. Premium is processed faster but takes longer overall because its consignment windows are twice as long.
Poshmark has no processing queue and no consignment window. An item is for sale as soon as you list it, and it stays yours until someone buys it. A listing that goes 60 days without seller activity is marked inactive, a label Poshmark is still rolling out; it can still be seen and bought, but Poshmark says active listings get more visibility. After a sale, the Shipping Policy gives you 7 days to ship before the buyer can cancel, and your earnings are released when the buyer accepts the order or 3 days after delivery.
So the two clocks measure different things. ThredUp's timeline is set by the company and has an end date. Poshmark's depends on when a buyer turns up, and then moves at the speed you ship.
Getting paid and cash-out fees
| ThredUp | Poshmark | |
|---|---|---|
| When earnings are issued | After the 14-day return window; final-sale items when they ship | When the buyer accepts, or 3 days after delivery |
| Form of earnings | ThredUp credit, convertible to cash or partner-brand credit | Earnings you redeem by one of the methods below |
| No-fee options | ThredUp credit spent on ThredUp | Direct deposit, 2–3 business days; check by mail, about 2 weeks |
| PayPal | $0.25 transfer fee; 24–48 hours; up to $1,000 at a time | $0.35 (PayPal or Venmo) |
| Bank or card transfer | Stripe direct deposit: $0.25 plus 1.5%; 1–3 business days; up to $3,000 at a time | Instant Transfer: $2; 30 minutes or less; up to $1,000 a day |
ThredUp's cash-out details come from a Help Center article last updated on March 8, 2024, so treat them as the terms at that date. On those terms, cashing out $100.00 leaves $99.75 through PayPal or $98.25 through Stripe. The article says ThredUp doesn't pay by cash or check, and that a first Stripe transfer can take up to a week.
Two more points from the same article. Any earnings in your ThredUp account are applied automatically to purchases you make on ThredUp, oldest first, and earnings not cashed out within a year are converted into an e-gift card that can be used only on ThredUp. Separately, the guide shows a 15% bonus if you convert earnings into shopping credit at one of its partner brands in place of cash (as shown on November 12, 2026).
Poshmark's redemption options include two with no fee. Instant Transfer needs an eligible Visa or Mastercard debit card, and the name on your payout account must match your legal name.
Returns and risk
On ThredUp you never deal with a buyer's return, but you wait for it. Buyers have 14 days to return an item unless it was sold as final sale, and your credit is issued only after that window closes. If the item comes back, it goes on sale again and its consignment window continues from the day it originally sold. If it sells a second time, you are paid as soon as that order ships.
The larger risk on ThredUp comes earlier. An item may not be accepted, and in a Standard Clean Out that means it is gone. An accepted item may not sell within its window. In the final 7 days of the window you can reclaim an item for $5.99 plus return shipping. If you don't, it becomes ThredUp's property, and ThredUp keeps it listed at falling prices.
On Poshmark the item stays in your hands until it sells, so nothing is forfeited if it doesn't. After a sale, all sales are final. A buyer can open a case only if the item doesn't arrive or isn't as described, and only within 72 hours of delivery. Fit and change of mind are not grounds for a return. If a case is opened, you have 6 hours to accept the return or offer a partial refund before Poshmark takes over the case, and a partial refund comes out of your earnings. Once earnings are released, the sale is final.
Poshmark also says a package sent with its label and scanned by USPS is fully covered if it is lost in transit. The full process is in Poshmark returns.
Effort required on each
| Task | ThredUp Clean Out | Poshmark |
|---|---|---|
| Sorting what qualifies | You, before packing | You |
| Listing each item | ThredUp | You: up to 16 photos and a title per listing |
| Pricing | ThredUp, with optional edits by you | You |
| Storing items until they sell | ThredUp | You |
| Packing and shipping each order | ThredUp | You, with Poshmark’s prepaid label |
| Buyer returns | ThredUp | You respond to any case within 6 hours |
| Number of shipments you make | One bag or box | One per order |
ThredUp's own Help Center recommends the Clean Out route for sellers who want a hands-off experience or have large quantities of items, and it names processing and photography among the work it takes on. Your part is one decision about what goes in the bag and one trip to a UPS drop-off.
On Poshmark the work repeats for every item. Shipping itself is simple: all orders go by USPS Ground Advantage with a label that covers up to 5 lbs, and the buyer pays for it. Poshmark shipping cost has the current label price and the charges for heavier packages.
ThredUp or Poshmark: which should you use?
This site has no sell-through data for either service, so it can't say how quickly an item will sell on Poshmark or how much of a bag will sell on ThredUp. The list below rests on each company's published rules and the payout math above.
- A few high-value branded pieces: Poshmark. You set the price and keep 80%. ThredUp's share matches that only in its $200 example, before a service fee and any price reductions. If you still want ThredUp to do the work, Premium is the version that lets you raise prices by up to 80% and sends back what it doesn't list.
- A large pile of mall-brand basics: the money is on Poshmark and the convenience is on ThredUp. A $20 sale pays $16.00 on Poshmark and $3.00 in ThredUp's example, and the first 5 such sales in a Standard bag only cover the fee. Our inference: treat a ThredUp bag of basics as a way to clear space with a small payout, not as income.
- No time to list: ThredUp. One bag replaces photographing, pricing, packing and shipping every item.
- You need cash quickly: Poshmark has the shorter path once an item sells, with earnings released on buyer acceptance or 3 days after delivery, and a $2 Instant Transfer. Most Standard Clean Outs take 10 to 14 weeks from bag order to final earnings.
- Men's clothing and other items outside ThredUp's list: Poshmark for men's fashion. For categories neither one takes, see where to sell clothes online.
- You live outside the 48 contiguous states: ThredUp's Clean Out isn't offered there.
- A mixed closet: our inference is that splitting it makes sense. List the pieces worth your time on Poshmark and send the rest, if it meets ThredUp's rules, in a bag.
If you choose Poshmark, the target profit calculator works out the list price that leaves the amount you want after the 20% fee. To compare Poshmark with other do-it-yourself apps, see Vinted vs Poshmark and Depop vs Poshmark.
ThredUp vs Poshmark: seller questions
Based on ThredUp's Clean Out Guide and Help Center and Poshmark's policies.
Is ThredUp or Poshmark better for selling clothes?
Poshmark is better if you want the most money and are willing to list, pack and ship each item: you keep 80% of a sale of $15 or more. ThredUp is better if you want the clothes gone with very little work: you mail a bag and ThredUp lists and ships the items, paying a share that runs from 3% of a $5 sale to 80% of a $200 sale in its published examples. A $50 sale pays $40.00 on Poshmark and $15.00 in ThredUp’s example.
Does ThredUp or Poshmark pay more?
Poshmark pays more at four of the five prices ThredUp publishes. On a $20 sale Poshmark pays $16.00 and ThredUp’s example pays $3.00; on $100 it is $80.00 against $60.00. Only at $200 do the two match, at $160.00 each, and that is before ThredUp deducts its service fee.
What fees does ThredUp charge sellers?
ThredUp charges a service fee of $14.99 for a Standard Clean Out or $34.99 for a Premium Clean Out. It is deducted from your earnings only after items sell, and if you earn less than the fee you aren’t charged the difference. A Standard bag costs $2.99, bags are free with Premium, and shipping labels for your own box are free. Its Help Center article on cashing out, last updated in March 2024, also lists a small transfer fee for PayPal and bank transfers.
Can you set your own price on ThredUp?
Only within limits. ThredUp’s algorithms set the price. You can then raise it by up to 10% on a Standard Clean Out or up to 80% on a Premium Clean Out, or lower it to as little as $4.99, any time before the item is added to a cart. ThredUp also lowers prices gradually and offers buyers discounts, and both can reduce your payout. On Poshmark you set the price yourself.
How long does ThredUp take to pay?
ThredUp’s guide says most Standard Clean Outs take 10 to 14 weeks from ordering a bag to the final earnings, and most Premium Clean Outs take 16 to 20 weeks, with earnings arriving along the way as items sell. Credit for each sold item is issued after the buyer’s 14-day return window. On Poshmark, earnings are released when the buyer accepts the order or 3 days after delivery.
What does ThredUp not accept?
ThredUp doesn’t accept men’s clothing and accessories, items without size tags (luxury brands and Lululemon excepted), undergarments, slips, PJs, slippers and robes, tailored, homemade or altered items, wedding dresses and ballgowns, work uniforms and adult costumes, or jewelry other than watches. Items also have to be clean and free of rips, pilling, fading and other flaws. Poshmark accepts men’s fashion.
What happens to clothes ThredUp doesn’t accept or sell?
Items ThredUp doesn’t list from a Standard Clean Out are reused or recycled and are not returned. Items it doesn’t list from a Premium Clean Out are returned to you by default. An accepted item that hasn’t sold can be reclaimed during the last 7 days of its consignment window for $5.99 per item plus return shipping. If you don’t reclaim it, it becomes ThredUp’s property.
How do you cash out on ThredUp and Poshmark?
ThredUp earnings arrive as ThredUp credit. Its Help Center article, last updated in March 2024, lists PayPal with a $0.25 transfer fee and Stripe direct deposit with a fee of $0.25 plus 1.5%. Poshmark offers direct deposit with no fee in 2 to 3 business days, Instant Transfer for $2, PayPal or Venmo for $0.35, and a check by mail with no fee.
Official sources & updates
These US sources were checked November 12, 2026. Examples are estimates, not settlement statements. Check your order for promotions, label charges, and seller-specific deductions. Canadian rates are outside this guide.
- ThredUp Clean Out Guide (earnings examples, pricing, timeline, what to send)
- ThredUp Help: How do ThredUp’s fees work? (updated August 28, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: What is a Clean Out Kit? (updated June 26, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: How do I order a Clean Out bag or label? (updated September 16, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: What clothing brands and categories are accepted? (updated September 8, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: What are ThredUp’s acceptance standards? (updated February 26, 2025)
- ThredUp Help: Items that aren’t accepted or don’t sell (updated August 18, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: How do I reclaim items? (updated April 14, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: Can you explain how I get paid out? (updated June 10, 2026)
- ThredUp Help: How do I find my earnings and cash out? (updated March 8, 2024)
- ThredUp Help: What is Direct Selling at ThredUp? (beta; updated October 10, 2026)
- Poshmark Fee Policy
- Poshmark Help: What can I sell on Poshmark?
- Poshmark Help: creating a listing (photos and title)
- Poshmark Help: Make an Offer
- Poshmark Shipping Policy
- Poshmark Help: when earnings are released and lost-package cover
- Poshmark Help: redemption options
- Poshmark Help: return policy and the 72-hour window
- Poshmark Help: how a return case works
Keep planning your next sale
Compare fees across marketplaces or dig into the full fee schedule for a platform.