Marketplace comparison · US / USD

Etsy vs eBay 2026: Which Is Better for Selling?

For most sellers the Etsy or eBay question is answered before fees come into it, because Etsy limits what a shop may list and eBay accepts almost anything. This guide starts with that rule, then compares size, fees, listing tools, shipping, payouts, returns and taxes using each company's published pages.

Sources checked By , ResaleMargin

Compare your own sale

Quick answer

Etsy and eBay suit different inventory. Etsy only accepts items you made, designed, handpicked or sourced under its Creativity Standards, which rules out reselling ordinary commercial goods unless they are vintage (at least 20 years old) or craft supplies. eBay accepts almost any item. Where an item qualifies for both, a normal Etsy order costs less in fees: on a $100 sale you keep $90.05 on Etsy and $86.00 on eBay in most categories. An order that follows an Etsy Offsite Ad adds 15% or 12%, which drops Etsy below eBay.

Etsy vs eBay at a glance

Rules for US sellers, checked November 12, 2026
EtsyeBay
What you may listItems you made, designed, handpicked or sourcedAlmost any item, within about 70 item policies
Reselling commercial goodsOnly vintage (at least 20 years old), craft and party supplies, and gift basketsAllowed
Active buyers worldwide, September 30, 202687.5 million147 million, including Depop and Tise
Cost to list$0.20 per listing, again every four monthsFirst 250 listings a month free, then $0.35 per listing in most categories
Fees on a sale6.5% transaction fee plus 3% + $0.25 payment processing13.6% + $0.40 in most categories; the rate depends on the category
Advertising chargeOffsite Ads: 15% or 12% of an order that follows an ad clickPromoted Listings: an ad rate you choose, from 2%
Listing formatsPriced listings with a four-month termAuction-style and fixed price
Return policySet by the seller for each listingSet by the seller; the Money Back Guarantee applies either way
When funds are availableNew sellers: generally 14 days after a saleGenerally about 2 days after payment is confirmed, unless on hold
Seller badgeStar SellerTop Rated Seller

What you're allowed to sell: the deciding difference

Etsy's Seller Policy requires everything listed to be made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller. Its Creativity Standards define those four groups:

  • Made by a seller: physical items made by hand or with the seller's own tools, including a 3D printer or Cricut machine. A store-bought item with only a superficial change doesn't count.
  • Designed by a seller: original designs produced or printed by a third party, or sold as a digital download.
  • Handpicked by a seller: vintage items, items from nature and certain curated collections. Vintage means at least 20 years old, and Etsy may ask for photos or details of an item's source and age.
  • Sourced by a seller: craft and party supplies, and items personalized with a buyer's own text or image.

Etsy defines reselling as selling a commercially available item the seller did not make or design. Its reselling rules permit that only for craft and party supplies, vintage items, and gift baskets that are not fully resold. The standards name what falls outside: resold commercial items newer than 20 years, even when designed to look vintage; resold clothing that is ready to wear as it is; and blank T-shirts, hats and tumblers. Drop-shipping is not allowed outside craft and party supplies. Etsy may remove a listing that breaks these rules without refunding the listing fee, and may suspend the account.

eBay's prohibited and restricted items page says you can sell “almost any item” and lists about 70 policies for specific kinds of goods. Two matter to most resellers: used clothing must be cleaned, with used underwear and socks banned, and counterfeits and unauthorized replicas are not allowed. So a thrifted jacket from 2019, a current pair of sneakers or a used phone can go on eBay but not on Etsy.

How big each marketplace is

Etsy's quarterly report for the period ended September 30, 2026, filed October 28, 2026, counts 87.5 million active buyers and 5.8 million active sellers, with about $2.65 billion of goods sold in the quarter. eBay's investor fast facts report 147 million active buyers and about 2.8 billion live listings as of September 30, 2026, figures that include Depop and Tise. Etsy sold Depop to eBay on July 30, 2026.

Both sets of numbers are worldwide, and both companies count a buyer as active after a purchase in the previous 12 months. eBay reports no separate figure for US buyers.

Our inference: eBay's larger total reflects a catalog that takes nearly every kind of product, so it doesn't show which site has more buyers for a handmade or vintage item.

Etsy vs eBay Calculator

Enter one sale price to see what each marketplace takes and what you keep.

$
$
$
$

Etsy leaves you $2.00 more on this sale.

Etsy

$44.80

profit after fees and costs

Listing Fee (one item)
−$0.20
Transaction Fee (6.5%)
−$3.25
Etsy Payments (US: 3% + $0.25)
−$1.75
Platform takes in total
$5.20 (10.40%)

eBay

$42.80

profit after fees and costs

eBay Final Value Fee (13.6%, Most categories)
−$6.80
Per-Order Fee ($0.40)
−$0.40
Platform takes in total
$7.20 (14.40%)

Etsy: $0.20 listing, 6.5% transaction, 3% + $0.25 processing, no Offsite Ad. eBay: most categories, no Store.

Fees side by side

Etsy charges three things on a US sale under its fee policy: a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus what you charge for shipping and gift wrap, and payment processing of 3% plus $0.25 on the full order total, sales tax included. The transaction fee does not apply to sales tax for US sellers. Together that is about 9.5% plus $0.45.

eBay charges one final value fee: 13.6% of the total in most categories up to $7,500 per item, plus $0.30 per order when the order is $10 or less, or $0.40 when it is more. That total counts shipping and sales tax.

What you keep before shipping and item cost, checked November 12, 2026
Sale priceEtsy, normal orderEtsy, Offsite Ad 15%Etsy, Offsite Ad 12%eBay, most categories
$15.00$13.12$10.87$11.32$12.56
$30.00$26.70$22.20$23.10$25.52
$50.00$44.80$37.30$38.80$42.80
$100.00$90.05$75.05$78.05$86.00
$300.00$271.05$226.05$235.05$258.80

The same item can carry a different price on each site. These prices pay out the same amount:

Price that returns each payout on a normal order, before shipping and item cost
You want to keepEtsy priceeBay priceDifference
$10.00$11.55$12.04$0.49
$25.00$28.12$29.40$1.28
$50.00$55.74$58.33$2.59
$100.00$110.99$116.20$5.21

For one marketplace at a time, use the Etsy fee calculator or the eBay fee calculator. To price from a profit goal with your item cost included, use the target profit calculator.

Offsite Ads versus Promoted Listings

Etsy advertises listings on sites such as Google, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest and Bing, and you can't choose which listings appear. Per Etsy's Offsite Ads help, when a buyer clicks one of these ads and orders from your shop within 30 days, Etsy charges an advertising fee on that order. Shops that have never reached $10,000 in sales in any 365-day period pay 15% and can opt out. Once a shop reaches $10,000 it pays 12% and must stay in for the life of the shop. The fee is charged on the item price plus shipping and gift wrap and is capped at $100 per order. If you are near that sales level, plan for those orders in your pricing.

eBay's ad fee is one you set. In a general Promoted Listings campaign you pick an ad rate between 2% and 100% of the sale total and pay it only when the item sells within 30 days of an ad click. Priority campaigns charge for each click instead. At a 5% ad rate a $50 eBay sale leaves $40.30, against $37.30 for an Etsy order with a 15% Offsite Ad. Etsy also sells on-site Etsy Ads, which are pay-per-click with a daily budget you set. eBay Promoted Listings covers eBay's campaign types.

What unsold listings cost

Etsy charges $0.20 for each listing whether or not it sells, and the listing lasts four months. With auto-renew on, a listing that never sells renews about three times a year:

Yearly Etsy listing cost if nothing sells and auto-renew stays on
Active listingsCost per yearCost per month
25$15.00$1.25
100$60.00$5.00
500$300.00$25.00

eBay gives sellers without a Store 250 free listings a month, then charges $0.35 per listing in most categories, and its fixed-price listings renew once per calendar month until you end them. For slow-moving stock, this difference can matter more than the sale percentage. The eBay Store guide covers larger allowances.

Where eBay's category rates change the result

Etsy's fee policy sets one transaction rate. eBay's rate depends on the category, so the gap is not the same for every item. The Etsy columns apply only if the item meets Etsy's rules, for example as vintage.

What you keep before shipping and item cost, no eBay Store, checked November 12, 2026
Category and priceeBayEtsy, normal orderEtsy, Offsite Ad 15%Keeps more on a normal order
Most categories, including clothing, $100.00$86.00$90.05$75.05Etsy
Jewelry, $100.00$84.60$90.05$75.05Etsy
Watches, $100.00$84.60$90.05$75.05Etsy
Books, movies and music, $100.00$84.30$90.05$75.05Etsy
Trading cards, $100.00$86.35$90.05$75.05Etsy
Athletic shoes at $150 or more, $200.00$184.00$180.55$150.55eBay

eBay charges 15% on jewelry up to $5,000 and on the first $1,000 of a watch, 15.3% on books, movies and music, and 13.25% on trading cards. For athletic shoes sold at $150 or more the rate is 8% and the per-order fee is dropped. All tiers are in eBay fees by category.

Listing formats and selling tools

Listing and selling tools compared
EtsyeBay
Formats and durationPriced listings that expire after four monthsAuctions of 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 days, or fixed price renewed each month
Photos and videoUp to 20 photos and 2 videosUp to 24 photos and one video
Offers from buyersOptional; the seller decides which listings take offersBest Offer on listings where you enable it; you have 24 hours to answer
Offers from the sellerPromo codes emailed automatically to shoppers who favorited an item or left it in a cartPrivate offers to buyers watching a listing, at least 5% off
Badge requirementsStar Seller: 95% of first messages answered within 24 hours, 95% of orders shipped on time with tracking, average rating of 4.8 or higherTop Rated: defect rate of 0.5% or less, tracking on 95% of orders, 100 transactions and $1,000 in US sales over 12 months

Auction-style listings are the main format difference; eBay may relist an auction automatically if it ends unsold. On offers, an Etsy buyer whose offer is accepted has 48 hours to complete the purchase and is not obligated to. eBay sellers can set automatic accept and decline limits; eBay Best Offer explains them.

Etsy's listing tools are built around made-to-order goods. A listing can carry variations on up to three attributes, each with its own price, quantity or SKU. Personalization allows up to five fields for a buyer's text, choices or uploaded file, and a text field can carry an added charge. Digital downloads can be instant or made to order, with up to five files of 20 MB each.

The badges work differently. Etsy reviews Star Seller status on the 1st of each month, requires at least 5 orders and $300 in sales over three months, and says the badge does not directly affect search ranking. eBay re-evaluates seller levels on the 20th. Per its Top Rated program page, Top Rated sellers get 10% off final value fees on listings that offer handling within one business day and free returns for 30 days or more. At the other end, eBay adds 6% to final value fees for Below Standard sellers, while an Etsy shop that misses the minimum service standards risks lower search visibility and its Purchase Protection eligibility.

Shipping: set by the seller on both

On both marketplaces the seller decides what the buyer pays for shipping and buys the label. Etsy sellers set a shipping price and a processing time on each listing, can offer free shipping, and can use calculated shipping with USPS. eBay sellers choose a flat rate, a rate calculated from the buyer's location, or free shipping. Both sell USPS, UPS and FedEx labels to US sellers. eBay puts the average saving on its labels at 33% against retail carrier rates, citing an internal comparison from March 2024; Etsy says its labels give access to some discounts.

Buyer-paid shipping is part of the fee base on both. Charging $6 for shipping on a $30 item adds $0.57 to Etsy's fees and $0.82 to eBay's. A full order shows the effect of tax as well. Take a $40 item with $7 buyer-paid shipping and $3.50 tax. Etsy's 6.5% transaction fee applies to the $47.00 of item and shipping, and its processing fee applies to the whole order. eBay's final value fee applies to the full total including tax. Including the shipping you collect, you receive $41.97 from Etsy and $39.73 from eBay, before paying for the label.

Etsy offers an optional free shipping guarantee that gives US buyers free shipping on items or orders of $35 and up; you still pay the carrier. For buyers abroad, eBay International Shipping takes over once your parcel reaches a domestic hub and costs the seller nothing extra; ship abroad without it and eBay adds a 1.65% international fee.

Getting paid

How the money reaches you
EtsyeBay
When funds are availableNew sellers: generally 14 days after a sale. Established shops: possibly the next business dayGenerally about 2 days after the buyer’s payment is confirmed, unless on hold
Deposit scheduleDaily (at least $25), weekly, biweekly or monthly; new sellers start on weekly, every MondayDaily, weekly, biweekly or monthly
Time to reach the bankUp to five business days after Etsy sends the depositGenerally 1–3 business days

Etsy adds each sale to your payment account and then sends scheduled deposits to your bank. The gap with eBay is widest for a new seller, whose Etsy funds generally wait 14 days. Etsy may also place a reserve on a new shop, holding a percentage of each physical sale; reserved funds are released once tracking shows the order in transit. Digital sales are not reserved, and Star Sellers get no reserve.

eBay's timing comes from its payments and earnings page. Its Seller Center also describes an express payout to a debit card, for a fee, that typically arrives within 30 minutes. Two Seller Center pages disagree about on-demand withdrawals for sellers on a daily schedule, so check eBay payout schedule.

Returns and buyer protection

Sellers set their own return policy on both. On Etsy you must state a policy on every physical listing, even if it is that you accept no returns, and accepting returns is optional. On eBay you choose no returns, or 30 or 60 days with either side paying return shipping.

Neither policy is the last word. Under the eBay Money Back Guarantee, a buyer gets 30 calendar days from delivery to send back an item that doesn't match the listing, even from a seller who offers no returns. The seller covers return shipping on such a return and must answer the request within 3 business days. When eBay has to step in, it refunds the buyer for the item and original shipping and collects that amount from the seller. The steps are in eBay returns.

On Etsy, a buyer first messages the seller, who has 48 hours to resolve the problem before a case can be opened. Cases can be opened until 30 days after the order's estimated delivery date, for an item that never arrived, arrived late or damaged, or doesn't match the listing. If Etsy finds the item doesn't match, the seller refunds the item, the original shipping and the return shipping.

Etsy's Purchase Protection Program can take that cost off the seller. On orders that meet its conditions, Etsy covers up to $250 of the refund, shipping and tax included, and the seller keeps the earnings. Any amount above $250 is charged to the seller. The conditions include shipping within your stated processing time, valid tracking or a label bought on Etsy, a listing that matches the item, and a reply to the buyer's help request within 48 hours. Damaged-item cases are covered only for the first instance in a calendar year. Etsy states the program is not insurance and that it decides each case at its own discretion.

eBay's seller protections work differently: valid tracking shields the seller from refunding a claim that an item never arrived, and a payment dispute decided against the seller costs a $20 dispute fee.

Opening a shop and getting started

Etsy has more steps before the first listing. Per its shop set-up page, a new seller verifies their identity with a photo of a government ID and a selfie, turns on two-factor authentication, and sets the shop up in a desktop browser. A one-time, non-refundable set-up fee may be charged; Etsy publishes no single amount, saying the cost varies by location and is shown during set-up. Etsy doesn't require a business license, and Etsy Payments is open to sellers aged 18 or older.

eBay applies selling limits that it reviews monthly. Active and sold listings both count toward the monthly limit, and a seller new to a category may face a separate limit there. The policy states no figures; each seller's own limit appears in Seller Hub.

Sales tax and tax forms

Both marketplaces collect and remit US sales tax for you in most states, with no charge and no action on your part; Etsy adds that sellers can't opt out. What differs is how tax feeds into fees. eBay calculates its final value fee on the order total with sales tax in it. On Etsy only the 3% processing fee touches the tax. Add $8 of sales tax to a $100 order and the payout falls by $1.09 on eBay and $0.24 on Etsy.

For income reporting, each company describes the same federal Form 1099-K threshold for tax year 2025, $20,000 in sales and 200 transactions, with lower thresholds in some states. Both say the form reports gross sales, not profit. 1099-K for resellers explains the form.

Etsy or eBay: which should you use?

Start from what you sell. One limit applies to the whole list: this site has no sell-through data for Etsy or eBay, so nothing here is a claim about where an item sells sooner.

  • Handmade goods and your own designs: both accept them. A normal Etsy order keeps you $2.00 more on a $50 sale than eBay in most categories, unless an Offsite Ad brings the order. Makers can also read Etsy vs Amazon Handmade.
  • Vintage, at least 20 years old: both. Etsy may ask for evidence of age. In eBay's 15% categories, such as jewelry, and watches up to $1,000, Etsy's fee advantage is larger.
  • Craft supplies: both, provided the item is a tool or material meant for making something by hand. Blank ready-to-use items don't qualify on Etsy.
  • Ordinary secondhand goods: eBay. Clothing, electronics and household items newer than 20 years are resold commercial goods under Etsy's rules.
  • Branded resale, new or used: eBay, unless the piece is old enough to be vintage. eBay bans counterfeits and unauthorized replicas.
  • Collectibles: eBay for anything under 20 years old, and either one for older pieces. eBay charges 13.25% on trading cards and offers auction-style listings. Our inference: an auction suits an item whose market price you don't know.
  • Digital downloads of your own work: Etsy lists them as an accepted item type and holds no reserve on digital sales.
  • An item that fits both: list on both and compare your own results before paying to renew slow Etsy listings. End the second listing when one sells: eBay records an unexpected seller cancellation as a defect.

Check real profit with your item cost and label included in the Etsy fee calculator and the eBay profit calculator.

Seller Knowledge Base

Etsy vs eBay: seller questions

What you can sell, fees, Offsite Ads and payouts.

Is Etsy or eBay better for selling?

It depends on what you sell. Etsy only accepts items you made, designed, handpicked or sourced under its Creativity Standards, so ordinary secondhand and retail goods belong on eBay, which accepts almost any item. For handmade goods, vintage items at least 20 years old and craft supplies, both are open to you, and a normal Etsy order costs less in fees: a $50 sale leaves $44.80 on Etsy and $42.80 on eBay in most categories.

Can I resell items on Etsy?

Only in three cases. Etsy allows reselling of craft and party supplies, vintage items that are at least 20 years old, and gift baskets that are not fully resold. Reselling any other commercially available item you did not make or design is against Etsy’s rules, and so is drop-shipping outside craft and party supplies. Etsy can remove the listing without refunding the listing fee and can suspend the account.

What counts as vintage on Etsy?

An item that is at least 20 years old and that the seller personally curated or collected. Etsy may ask for photos or information about a vintage item’s source, age, designer or materials. A newer commercial item does not qualify, even if it is designed to look vintage.

Is Etsy cheaper than eBay?

On a normal sale, usually yes. Etsy costs about 9.5% plus $0.45 including the listing fee; eBay costs 13.6% plus $0.40 in most categories. On a $50 item you keep $44.80 on Etsy and $42.80 on eBay.

When does Etsy cost more than eBay?

When an order follows a click on an Etsy Offsite Ad. Etsy then adds 15%, or 12% for shops that have reached $10,000 in sales in a 365-day period. A $50 item drops to $37.30 on Etsy at 15%, below eBay’s $42.80.

Can I opt out of Etsy Offsite Ads?

Shops that have never reached $10,000 in sales in any 365-day period can opt out. A shop that reaches $10,000 must participate and pays the 12% rate for the lifetime of the shop, even if its sales later fall.

Does Etsy charge for listings that don’t sell?

Yes. Etsy charges $0.20 per listing whether or not the item sells, and a listing lasts four months. With auto-renew on, each unsold listing costs another $0.20 at every renewal. eBay gives sellers without a Store 250 free listings a month and charges $0.35 per listing after that in most categories.

How long do Etsy and eBay take to pay sellers?

For a new Etsy seller, funds are generally eligible for deposit 14 days after a sale; for an established shop they may be available the next business day. Etsy then deposits on your schedule, and a deposit can take up to five business days to reach your bank. eBay generally makes funds available about 2 days after it confirms the buyer’s payment, unless they are on hold, and a bank generally takes 1–3 business days after a payout is sent.

Official sources & updates

These US sources were checked November 12, 2026. Examples are estimates, not settlement statements. Check your order for promotions, label charges, and seller-specific deductions. Canadian rates are outside this guide.