Marketplace comparison · US / USD
Etsy vs Amazon Handmade 2026: Which Is Better for Selling?
A maker choosing between Etsy and Amazon Handmade faces two questions before fees: will the marketplace let you in, and does the way you make things fit its definition of handmade. This guide covers both, then compares fees, listing tools, shipping, payouts and returns using each company's published pages.
Sources checked By Akasha Ahmed, ResaleMargin
Calculate your Etsy feesQuick answer
Etsy is open to more kinds of maker and costs less on a normal order; Amazon Handmade is an approval-only store for goods you produce yourself, with one 15% fee and access to FBA. Etsy also takes vintage items, craft supplies and your own designs made by a production partner, none of which Handmade allows. Where an item fits both, a $50 sale leaves $44.80 on Etsy and $42.50 on Handmade, unless an Etsy Offsite Ad brought the order, which drops Etsy to $37.30.
Etsy vs Amazon Handmade at a glance
| Etsy | Amazon Handmade | |
|---|---|---|
| Getting in | No application; identity check and a set-up fee | Application and audit; Professional selling plan |
| Outside production | Allowed for your own designs, if disclosed | Prohibited |
| Vintage and craft supplies | Allowed | No reselling; supplies only if you made or altered them |
| Cost to list | $0.20 a listing, charged again at each four-month renewal | Free |
| Fees on a sale | 6.5% plus 3% + $0.25 processing | 15%, minimum $0.30 |
| Subscription | Etsy Plus is optional at $10 a month | $39.99 a month, waived after a one-time first-month payment |
| Extra charge on some orders | Offsite Ads: 15% or 12% after an ad click | FBA fees, if you use FBA |
| Returns | Seller sets a policy on each listing | Accepted for 30 days; customized items excepted |
| When funds are available | Generally 14 days after a sale for a new seller | 7 days after delivery, then a 14-day payout cycle |
Getting in: an application versus a set-up process
Amazon Handmade screens makers before they list. Its program page gives the order: register as a Professional seller, apply to be a Handmade maker, then list products and create a maker profile. Seller Central's eligibility page requires an approved Amazon selling account on a Professional plan. The application asks for:
- your name and email;
- details of your design and production processes, without which Amazon says an application will not be accepted;
- pictures of your work that clearly show your business name, logo or business card.
Amazon approves independent makers working alone or, preferably, with fewer than 20 friends, family members or employees, and collaborative groups such as cooperatives and nonprofits. It can review makers later and remove those that break its rules.
Etsy has no application or audit, but opening a shop is not instant. Per its shop-opening guide, you set the shop up in a desktop browser, verify your identity with a photo of a government ID and a selfie, and turn on two-factor authentication. A one-time, non-refundable set-up fee is then charged to your card where one applies. Etsy says the cost varies by location and is displayed during set-up.
Our inference: Amazon checks how you make things before you can list, while Etsy checks who you are and enforces its item rules afterward, by removing listings and suspending accounts.
What counts as handmade on each
This decides eligibility. Etsy's Creativity Standards cover four groups of items: made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller. Amazon requires Handmade products to be designed and produced by you or your small group.
| Kind of item or method | Etsy | Amazon Handmade |
|---|---|---|
| Machines and tools | Your own tools, including a 3D printer, CNC or Cricut machine in your shop or home | Hand tools and light machinery in a home, studio or workspace; no assembly lines or automation |
| A bought item you alter | Allowed when altered with specialized handcrafting skills; a simple stick-on adornment is not enough | Allowed (hand-altered), such as a T-shirt or mug with a graphic; used items may be upcycled or repurposed |
| Your design, produced by another company | Allowed with a disclosed production partner, including print-on-demand | Not allowed: outsourcing of production is prohibited |
| Who may make it | You, or a production partner working from your original design | You and a small group of family members or employees; 20 or fewer is preferred |
| Vintage | Allowed if at least 20 years old and personally curated | Reselling is prohibited |
| Craft supplies | Allowed: tools or materials meant for making a new item by hand | Only in a DIY kit, or supplies you made or hand-altered, such as dyed yarn |
| Digital downloads, food and electronics | Digital downloads of your own original work are allowed | None of the three is allowed |
| Drop-shipping | Not allowed, except craft and party supplies | Prohibited |
The production-partner row matters most to print-on-demand sellers. Etsy's reselling and production rules let a printing service, apparel producer or engraver make and ship items, provided the design is the seller's original or the buyer's customization, and the Seller Policy requires the partner to be disclosed in the listing. Using a partner for products you did not design breaks Etsy's rules.
Handmade also limits categories. Amazon's program page lists Accessories, Artwork, Baby, Beauty & Personal Care, Clothing, Shoes & Handbags, Home, Outdoor & Home Care, Jewelry & Watches, Kitchen & Dining, Pet Supplies, Sporting Goods, Stationery & Party Supplies, and Toys & Games, and says items from unlisted categories may not be sold in the Handmade store. Seller Central names the categories slightly differently.
Fees and what you keep
Etsy's fee policy stacks several charges on a US sale:
- Listing fee: $0.20 per listing, owed whether or not the item sells. A listing expires after four months and renews for another $0.20.
- Transaction fee: 6.5% of the item price, the shipping you charge and any gift-wrap charge. A paid personalization option counts as part of the price.
- Payment processing: 3% plus $0.25 of the full order total, including shipping and any sales tax, under the Etsy Payments Policy.
- Offsite Ads: 15% or 12% of an order that follows an ad click, covered in the next section.
Amazon Handmade has one selling fee. Seller Central's Handmade fee page sets the referral fee at 15% with a $0.30 minimum, taken on what the buyer pays for the item, shipping and gift wrap, excluding tax. Listing is free, and Amazon says it charges no transaction or processing fees. The 15% rate applies only to approved makers on a Professional plan; an approved maker who has not upgraded pays Amazon's standard referral fees.
The Professional plan normally costs $39.99 a month. Amazon's program page says that after a one-time first-month payment the monthly fee is waived for approved Handmade sellers, a saving it puts at $480 a year. Some Amazon pages describe the waiver without mentioning the first payment.
| Sale price | Etsy, normal order | Etsy, Offsite Ad 15% | Etsy, Offsite Ad 12% | Amazon Handmade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5.00 | $4.07 | $3.32 | $3.47 | $4.25 |
| $10.00 | $8.60 | $7.10 | $7.40 | $8.50 |
| $15.00 | $13.12 | $10.87 | $11.32 | $12.75 |
| $25.00 | $22.17 | $18.42 | $19.17 | $21.25 |
| $50.00 | $44.80 | $37.30 | $38.80 | $42.50 |
| $100.00 | $90.05 | $75.05 | $78.05 | $85.00 |
| $200.00 | $180.55 | $150.55 | $156.55 | $170.00 |
Etsy figures include the $0.20 listing fee. Handmade figures leave out the first-month plan payment and any FBA fees.
Both take their percentage on buyer-paid shipping. A $30 item with $6 shipping returns $32.13 on Etsy and $30.60 on Handmade, before you buy the label. Sales tax differs: Handmade's fee excludes it, while Etsy's 3% processing fee applies to it, so $8 of tax on a $100 Etsy order costs $0.24. Run your own numbers in the Etsy fee calculator, check standard Amazon categories and FBA in the Amazon fee calculator, or price from a profit goal with the target profit calculator.
When Etsy's stacked fees exceed Handmade's 15%
There are two cases. The first is a low price: below about $8.30, Etsy's fixed $0.45 outweighs its lower percentage, and a $5 sale leaves $4.25 on Handmade and $4.07 on Etsy. At $10 Etsy is ahead by $0.10, and its lead grows with the price.
The second is an Offsite Ads order. Etsy advertises listings on other sites, and its Offsite Ads page says sellers can't choose which listings appear. If a shopper clicks an ad and orders from your shop within 30 days, Etsy adds a fee on the item price plus shipping and gift wrap, capped at $100 per order. A shop that has never reached $10,000 in sales in any 365-day period pays 15% and may opt out. Once a shop reaches $10,000, the rate is 12% and participation is required for the life of the shop, even if sales later fall.
An order with the ad fee always pays less than Handmade, so what matters is how many orders carry it. This table shows the share of orders that would have to come through Offsite Ads before Etsy's average payout falls to Handmade's.
| Sale price | Etsy lead on a normal order | Break-even ad share at 15% | Break-even ad share at 12% |
|---|---|---|---|
| $25.00 | $0.92 | 25% | 31% |
| $50.00 | $2.30 | 31% | 38% |
| $100.00 | $5.05 | 34% | 42% |
| $200.00 | $10.55 | 35% | 44% |
These shares are our arithmetic from the fee rules, not a forecast of how many orders ads will bring.
Listing tools: personalization, variations and customization
| Etsy | Amazon Handmade | |
|---|---|---|
| Buyer personalization | Up to 5 fields per listing: text box, list of options or file upload | Amazon Custom: buyers add text or upload an image |
| Options and variations | Variations on up to 3 attributes, each with its own price, quantity or SKU | Amazon Custom: option lists you set, up to 100 options per product |
| Cost of personalization | You can add a price of $0.20 to $500 to an optional text field | Amazon Custom is free with a Professional plan |
Etsy's personalization fields are added listing by listing, and a seller who enables custom order requests can turn a request into a custom listing.
On Handmade, personalization runs through Amazon Custom, a separate program you register for, and customized products must be fulfilled by the seller. Amazon also asks for a product ID or an exemption request when you list, and offers a tool that imports product details from Etsy.
Shipping and fulfillment
On Etsy the seller packs and ships every order. You set a shipping price and a processing time on each listing, and the processing time fixes the ship-by date. US sellers can buy USPS, UPS and FedEx labels on Etsy.
Handmade makers can ship orders themselves or use Fulfillment by Amazon. With FBA you send stock to Amazon's fulfillment centers, and Amazon picks, packs and ships each order and handles customer service and returns. Three limits apply:
- Personalized or customized items are not eligible, so only non-customized listings can be enrolled.
- FBA charges per unit for storage and fulfillment, and Amazon states that the Handmade referral fee is in addition to FBA or shipping charges.
- Our inference: because stock must be made before it is sent in, FBA suits repeatable products more than made-to-order work.
FBA rates are covered in Amazon vs eBay fees.
Getting paid
| Etsy | Amazon Handmade | |
|---|---|---|
| When funds become available | Generally 14 days after a sale for a new seller; as soon as the next business day for an established shop | Standard reserve: 7 days after the delivery date |
| Payout schedule | Daily, weekly, biweekly or monthly; new sellers default to weekly, on Mondays | 14-day payout period; available funds can also be requested once every 24 hours |
| Time to reach the bank | Up to five business days from when Etsy sends it | Up to five business days after Amazon initiates the payment |
A Handmade maker is paid through the Amazon selling account that Handmade requires, under Amazon's reserve policy. For someone who has just started selling, Amazon says it is normal for all funds to be held in reserve.
Etsy's deposit page describes a separate reserve. Etsy may apply one to a shop that is new or that it considers a risk, keeping back a percentage of each physical-item sale until tracking shows the order in transit.
For tax reporting, both companies describe a federal Form 1099-K threshold of $20,000 and 200 transactions, Etsy for tax year 2025. 1099-K for resellers explains the form.
Returns, protection and seller standards
An Etsy seller writes the return policy for each physical listing. Accepting returns is optional, but a policy must be stated, even one that says no returns. Amazon's Handmade returns page says makers must match or exceed Amazon's policy and accept return requests within 30 days of the customer receiving the shipment.
Customized work is the exception on Amazon: items offered with customization options are ineligible for returns but stay under the A-to-z Guarantee, which covers timely delivery and item condition on orders the seller fulfills.
On Etsy the seller gets 48 hours to settle a complaint before the buyer can open a case. When Etsy rules that an item is not what the listing showed, the seller owes the item price and the shipping in both directions. The Purchase Protection Program can take that refund off a maker's hands: for an eligible order Etsy pays up to $250, a limit that counts shipping and tax, and you keep what you earned. Eligibility requires shipping inside your stated processing time, valid tracking or a label bought on Etsy, and an accurate listing. Etsy calls the program neither insurance nor a guarantee.
Both set performance minimums. Amazon measures seller-fulfilled orders only: an Order Defect Rate under 1% over 60 days, a cancellation rate under 2.5%, a late shipment rate under 4% and valid tracking on more than 95% of shipments. Missing them can lead to suspension of seller-fulfilled selling. Etsy's customer service standards ask for replies to 80% of first messages within 48 hours and 80% of orders shipped on time; a shop that falls short risks lower search visibility and may lose Purchase Protection.
Etsy or Amazon Handmade: which should you use?
This site has no sell-through data for Etsy or Amazon Handmade, so nothing below is a claim about where an item sells sooner. Amazon publishes no buyer count for the Handmade store.
- Made-to-order personalized items: both support them. Etsy lets you set the processing time and return policy. Handmade needs Amazon Custom, you ship every order yourself, and customized items are not returnable.
- A design printed by a production partner: Etsy only, with the partner disclosed. Handmade prohibits outsourced production.
- Vintage and craft supplies: Etsy only. Handmade prohibits reselling and takes supplies only when you made or altered them or they are part of a DIY kit.
- Items priced under $15: the gap is small either way. Handmade keeps more below about $8.30; at $15 Etsy is ahead by $0.37. On Etsy, each unsold listing also costs $0.20 every four months.
- You want someone else to pack and ship: Handmade, through FBA, for non-customized stock. Add FBA's per-unit fees to the 15% before comparing.
- You want your own shop identity: Etsy gives each seller a named shop and sells Pattern, a standalone-site tool at $15 a month after a 30-day trial. Handmade gives you a maker profile and a free storefront inside Amazon. For a store on your own domain, see the Shopify fee calculator.
- You make everything yourself and it fits both: a normal Etsy order keeps $2.30 more on a $50 sale. Trying Handmade as well costs an application and a one-time $39.99.
For goods that are not handmade, see Etsy vs eBay.
Etsy vs Amazon Handmade: maker questions
Eligibility, fees, print-on-demand and FBA.
Is Etsy or Amazon Handmade better for selling?
It depends on what you make and how you make it. Etsy has no application and also accepts vintage items, craft supplies and your own designs made by a disclosed production partner. Amazon Handmade admits only approved makers who produce the goods themselves or with a small team. Where an item fits both, a normal Etsy order costs less above about $8.30: a $50 sale leaves $44.80 on Etsy and $42.50 on Handmade.
Is Etsy cheaper than Amazon Handmade?
On a normal order above about $8.30, yes. Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee and 3% plus $0.25 for payment processing; Handmade charges 15% with a $0.30 minimum. An Etsy order that follows an Offsite Ad click costs a further 15% or 12%, which leaves $37.30 or $38.80 on a $50 sale, below Handmade’s $42.50.
Do I need approval to sell on Amazon Handmade?
Yes. You need an Amazon selling account on the Professional plan, and then you apply to Handmade with details of your design and production processes and pictures of your work that show your business name, logo or business card. Etsy has no application or audit, but a new shop must verify the owner’s identity, turn on two-factor authentication and pay a one-time set-up fee where one applies.
What are Amazon Handmade’s fees?
A referral fee of 15% or $0.30, whichever is greater, on the item price plus any shipping or gift-wrap charge. Listing is free. Handmade requires the Professional selling plan at $39.99 a month; after a one-time first-month payment, the monthly fee is waived for approved makers. FBA fees are extra if you use FBA.
Can I sell print-on-demand products on Etsy or Amazon Handmade?
On Etsy, yes, if the design is your own. Etsy allows production partners, including print-on-demand services, to produce and ship your original designs, and you must disclose the partner in the listing. Amazon Handmade prohibits outsourcing of production and drop-shipping, so a design that another company prints and ships does not qualify there.
Can Amazon Handmade sellers use FBA?
Yes, for listings that are not customized. Amazon says personalized or customized Handmade items are not eligible for Fulfillment by Amazon and must be shipped by the maker. With FBA, Amazon packs and ships orders and handles customer service and returns, and its fulfillment fees come on top of the 15% referral fee.
Official sources & updates
These US sources were checked November 12, 2026. Examples are estimates, not settlement statements. Check your order for promotions, label charges, and seller-specific deductions. Canadian rates are outside this guide.
- Etsy Creativity Standards (last updated June 10, 2025)
- Etsy Seller Policy (last updated October 5, 2026)
- Etsy Help: reselling, drop shipping and production partner rules
- Etsy Help: how to open an Etsy shop
- Etsy Fees & Payments Policy (last updated October 5, 2026)
- Etsy Payments Policy (US processing 3% + $0.25; read November 12, 2026)
- Etsy Help: How Offsite Ads work
- Etsy Help: personalization and custom orders
- Etsy Help: deposit schedules and payment account
- Etsy Help: return and exchange policies
- Etsy Help: Purchase Protection Program for sellers
- Etsy Help: customer service standards
- Amazon Handmade program page
- Amazon Seller Central: Handmade eligibility, application and product rules
- Amazon Seller Central: Handmade referral fees
- Amazon Seller Central: Handmade returns
- Amazon Custom program page
- Fulfillment by Amazon program page
- Amazon Seller Central: delivery date-based reserve policy
- Amazon Seller Central: Order Defect Rate
Keep planning your next sale
Compare fees across marketplaces or dig into the full fee schedule for a platform.