Marketplace comparison · US / USD

Amazon vs eBay 2026: Which Is Better for Selling?

Amazon and eBay are organized differently, and that decides more than the fee rate does. Amazon is a product catalog where sellers attach offers to shared product pages. eBay is a marketplace of listings that each seller writes. This guide compares the two for US sellers using what each company publishes.

Sources checked By , ResaleMargin

Open the Amazon fee calculator

Quick answer

Amazon and eBay suit different inventory. On Amazon you add an offer to a shared product page, most categories need a product ID such as a UPC, and some categories, brands and products need approval. On eBay you write your own listing and can sell almost any item, used or new. Where an item fits both, a $100 sale in a standard category leaves $86.00 on eBay, $84.01 on Amazon's Individual plan and $85.00 on its Professional plan before the $39.99 monthly fee.

Amazon vs eBay at a glance

Rules for US sellers, checked November 12, 2026
AmazoneBay
How you listAdd an offer to a shared product page, or create a page with a product IDWrite your own listing for each item
Cost to start$0.99 per item sold (Individual) or $39.99 a month (Professional)250 free listings a month, then $0.35 each in most categories
Fee on a saleReferral fee: 15% in many categories, $0.30 minimum13.6% + $0.40 in most categories
Fee is charged onItem price, shipping and gift wrap; sales tax excludedItem price, shipping and sales tax
What may be listedDepends on category, brand and condition; some need approvalAlmost any item, within about 70 item policies
Used itemsAllowed in some categories; new only in toys, beauty, baby and groceryAllowed; used clothing must be cleaned
FulfilmentFulfillment by Amazon, or ship orders yourselfYou ship, with flat, calculated or free shipping
When funds are released7 days after delivery, then a 14-day payout cycleGenerally about 2 days after payment is confirmed, unless on hold
ReturnsAmazon’s policy applies: most items within 30 daysYou set the policy; the Money Back Guarantee applies either way
Performance minimumOrder Defect Rate under 1%Transaction defect rate of 2% or less

Selling plans and the cost to start

Amazon's pricing page offers two plans. Individual has no subscription and costs $0.99 for each item sold. Professional costs $39.99 a month with no per-item fee, charged whether or not you sell anything. Both pay referral fees, listing is free on both, and you can switch at any time. $39.99 ÷ $0.99 is about 40.4, so Individual is cheaper below 40 sales a month and Professional is cheaper from 41.

Advertising, Automate Pricing, bulk listing and Amazon Business need a Professional account. Individual sellers can't set their own shipping charges. Fulfillment by Amazon works with either plan. Amazon also says some categories require a Professional plan.

Registration asks for a government ID, a chargeable credit card, a bank account and tax information, and Amazon says identity verification usually takes three business days or less. Amazon's registration page mentions a one-time registration fee for new Professional sellers without stating the amount.

eBay has no plan to pick. A seller without a Store gets 250 listings a month with no insertion fee and pays $0.35 per listing after that in most categories. A Store subscription is optional; a Basic Store or higher lowers the most-categories rate to 12.7%, and the eBay Store guide shows when that pays for itself. eBay applies selling limits that it reviews monthly, and its limits page states no figures.

What you can sell, and in what condition

For used and one-off items this section usually settles the choice. Amazon restricts products at five levels: individual products, brands, brands within a category, categories and sub-categories. Its category table sets the conditions allowed in each category and says whether the category itself needs approval.

Selected rows from Amazon’s category table, checked November 12, 2026
Amazon categoryConditions allowedCategory approval
Apparel; shoesNew, usedNo
BooksNew, used, collectibleNo
Consumer electronics; cameras; personal computersNew, usedNo
Video gamesNew, usedNo
ToysNewNo
Beauty; baby products other than apparel; groceryNew onlyNo
Music; video, DVD and Blu-rayNew, used, collectibleYes
Collectible coins; entertainment collectibles; sports memorabiliaNew, used, collectibleYes
AutomotiveNew; used like new needs approvalNo for new

A category that needs no approval can still be closed to you for a given brand. Amazon says many brands have their own restrictions beyond the category rules. You can check a product before buying stock: in Seller Central, choose Add a Product and search for it. “Sell this product” means no approval is needed, “Apply to sell” means approval is required, and “Not Available” means it can't be listed.

An approval application can ask for purchase invoices dated within 180 days, product photos and a brand authorization letter. Amazon reviews it in 2 to 7 business days, and a “Your account does not qualify” result can't be appealed. Amazon advises keeping receipts and invoices as proof of authenticity.

Condition has its own rules. Amazon's condition guidelines give four used grades: Like New, Very Good, Good and Acceptable, plus Collectible in some categories. An item can't be listed in any condition if it is not clean, needs repair, is missing essential parts, or was distributed as a promotional copy or sample.

eBay's prohibited and restricted items page says you can sell “almost any item” and lists about 70 item policies. Used clothing must be cleaned, used underwear and socks are banned, and counterfeits and unauthorized replicas are not allowed.

How listings and competition work

An Amazon listing has two parts: a product detail page, and each seller's offer with a price and shipping terms. When several sellers offer the same product, their offers share one page. A reseller usually matches an offer to a page that already exists. Creating a new page requires a product ID in most categories: a UPC, EAN or ISBN. Amazon checks IDs against the GS1 database, bans false ones, and lets you request an exemption if the product has no ID.

On a shared page, one offer is the Featured Offer, the one shown with the Add to Cart and Buy Now buttons; the older name is the Buy Box. Amazon says a competitive price, counting shipping, fast and free delivery and free returns make an offer more likely to be featured and that an out-of-stock offer can't be. Other offers stay visible in the All Offer Display.

Amazon's eligibility notice says that as of September 2026 it no longer maintains a seller eligibility requirement, and offers from all sellers can be evaluated for the Featured Offer. A separate Seller Central page about the subscription fee still lists “eligibility for top placement on detail pages” as a Professional benefit; the dated notice is the more specific of the two.

On eBay each listing is yours: an 80-character title, up to 24 photos, one video and your own description. Auction-style listings run for 1, 3, 5, 7 or 10 days, and fixed-price listings renew monthly until the item sells or you end them. You can add Best Offer to a listing, and Promoted Listings are optional paid ads.

Our inference: on Amazon, sellers of the same product compete mainly on price and delivery, because the page is shared. On eBay, the photos and description of your particular item are part of the offer, which matters when its condition is what the buyer is judging.

What you keep from $10 to $500

Payout after marketplace fees in a standard category, before shipping, fulfilment and item cost
Sale priceeBayAmazon IndividualAmazon Professional (before $39.99/mo)
$10.00$8.34$7.51$8.50
$20.00$16.88$16.01$17.00
$50.00$42.80$41.51$42.50
$100.00$86.00$84.01$85.00
$200.00$172.40$169.01$170.00
$500.00$431.60$424.01$425.00

The Amazon columns use the 15% referral fee with its $0.30 minimum, and the Individual column subtracts $0.99 per item. The eBay column uses 13.6% plus the per-order fee, with no Store and no ads. To add your item cost and work back from a profit goal, use the target profit calculator.

Same comparison by category, before shipping, fulfilment and item cost, checked November 12, 2026
Item and priceeBayAmazon IndividualAmazon Professional (before $39.99/mo)
Standard category, $50.00$42.80$41.51$42.50
Clothing, $15.00$12.56$13.26$14.25
Clothing, $40.00$34.16$32.21$33.20
Book, $15.00$12.30$9.96$10.95
Athletic shoes, $200.00$184.00$169.01$170.00
Handbag, $200.00$169.60$169.01$170.00
Jewelry, $100.00$84.60$79.01$80.00
Watch, $300.00$254.60$251.01$252.00

Amazon fees: referral, closing and FBA

The referral fee is a percentage of the total sales price or a per-item minimum, whichever is greater. The total sales price is the item price plus delivery and gift-wrap charges, and it excludes sales tax that Amazon collects.

Selected Amazon referral fees, checked November 12, 2026
CategoryReferral feeMinimum
Everything Else; Home and Kitchen; Toys and Games; Footwear15%$0.30
Clothing and Accessories5% at $15 or less, 10% over $15 to $20, 17% over $20$0.30
Consumer Electronics; Computers8%$0.30
Electronics Accessories15% up to $100, 8% on the portion above$0.30
Beauty, Health and Personal Care; Baby Products8% at $10 or less, 15% above$0.30
Jewelry20% up to $250, 5% on the portion above$0.30
Watches16% up to $1,500, 3% on the portion above$0.30
Media: books, DVD, music, software, video15%, plus a $1.80 closing feeNone

The $1.80 closing fee applies per unit to books, DVDs, music, software, video games, consoles and game accessories. It is separate from the $0.99 per-item fee, so an Individual seller pays both on a book. The Amazon fee calculator applies your category.

Fulfillment by Amazon adds a per-unit fulfilment fee that depends on product type, size tier, shipping weight and price band. The rates below are from Amazon's FBA rate cards for non-apparel items priced $10 to $50. Apparel has its own, higher table.

FBA fulfilment fee per unit, non-apparel, $10 to $50, before the 3.5% surcharge
Size tier and weightJan 15 – Oct 14, 2026Peak: Oct 15, 2026 – Jan 14, 2027From Jan 15, 2027
Small standard, over 6 oz to 8 oz$3.54$3.74$3.97
Large standard, over 12 oz to 16 oz$4.60$4.89$4.67
Large standard, over 1.75 lb to 2 lb$5.82$6.15$5.98

A 3.5% fuel and logistics surcharge has applied to these fees since April 17, 2026. For a large standard item over 12 oz and up to 1 lb in the peak period that runs from October 15, 2026 to January 14, 2027, that is $4.89 × 1.035 = $5.06. On a $30.00 sale in a 15% category, $30.00 − $4.50 referral − $5.06 fulfilment leaves $20.44 on the Professional plan, before storage and the cost of sending stock to Amazon. The same sale on eBay leaves $25.52 before you pay for the label.

Monthly storage for standard-size items is $0.78 per cubic foot from January to September and $2.40 from October to December, under rates effective until January 31, 2027. An aged inventory surcharge starts at 181 days. Amazon says it will merge the two into a single age-based rate on February 1, 2027.

eBay fees: one final value fee

eBay's selling fees page sets a final value fee of 13.6% in most categories on the total amount of the sale up to $7,500 per item, and 2.35% on the portion above. A per-order fee is added: $0.30 on orders of $10 or less and $0.40 on larger orders. The total includes the item price, shipping the buyer pays and sales tax.

Some categories differ. Books, movies and music pay 15.3%. Athletic shoes pay 8% with no per-order fee when the sale is $150 or more. Women's handbags pay 15% up to $2,000, jewelry 15% up to $5,000 and watches 15% on the first $1,000. Clothing has no row of its own and pays the most-categories rate. Every tier is in eBay fees by category, and the eBay fee calculator handles a single sale.

Fulfilment and shipping

Amazon gives you two routes, and you can mix them. With Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) you send stock to Amazon's fulfilment centers, and Amazon picks, packs and ships each order and handles customer service and returns. With Fulfilled by Merchant you store and ship the item yourself and confirm shipment within your stated handling time. The Prime badge is available to sellers enrolled in FBA or in Seller Fulfilled Prime.

Shipping charges depend on the plan. Professional sellers set their own shipping rates. For an Individual seller, Amazon charges the buyer a standard amount and credits it to you: $3.99 for a book at standard speed and $4.49 plus $0.50 per pound in most other categories. You must ship the order even if the credit is less than your cost.

On eBay the seller chooses the charge: a flat rate, a rate calculated from the buyer's location, or free shipping. eBay Labels cover USPS, UPS and FedEx, and eBay says they average 33% off retail carrier rates, based on its internal comparison as of March 2024.

Both marketplaces charge their fee on buyer-paid shipping. Charging $6 for shipping on a $30 item adds $0.90 to a 15% Amazon referral fee and $0.82 to eBay's fee.

Getting paid

From sale to your bank
AmazoneBay
When funds are releasedStandard reserve: 7 days after the delivery dateGenerally within about 2 days of confirming the buyer’s payment, unless on hold
Payout cycleEvery 14 days; Disburse on Demand allows one request every 24 hoursDaily, weekly, biweekly or monthly
Time to reach the bankUp to five business daysGenerally 1–3 business days
Paid toA bank account; not a credit card or PayPalYour bank; express payout to a debit card for a fee

Amazon's reserve policy gives this example: an item sold on January 1 and delivered on January 6 becomes available for disbursement on January 14. It says the reserve period may be extended after a risk assessment, and that it is normal for all of a new seller's funds to be held in reserve at first.

eBay's timing is on its payments and earnings page. eBay says funds from orders may be held for Below Standard sellers. Schedules and holds are covered in eBay payout schedule.

Returns and buyer guarantees

Amazon sellers who ship their own orders don't set a return policy. Amazon's returns page says they must follow its policy, which allows most items to be returned within 30 days, with windows that vary by category. Amazon authorizes in-policy requests automatically, and you must refund within two business days of receiving a return. Starting December 18, 2026, every US seller-fulfilled return except Heavy and Bulky items must include a prepaid return label: within 7 calendar days of the request you either upload a prepaid label or refund in full without asking for the item back. For a buyer-fault return you may deduct the return shipping cost from the refund.

The A-to-z Guarantee covers seller-fulfilled orders for timely delivery and for the item's condition. You have 48 hours to answer the buyer's message and try to resolve the problem. With FBA, Amazon handles returns.

eBay sellers choose a policy: no returns, or 30 or 60 days with either side paying return shipping. The eBay Money Back Guarantee sits above that choice. A buyer has 30 calendar days from delivery to return an item that doesn't match the listing, the seller pays that return shipping, and the seller has 3 business days to respond. A change-of-mind return can be refused under a no-returns policy. The process is in eBay returns.

Performance standards

Amazon measures seller-fulfilled orders against fixed targets. The Order Defect Rate must stay under 1%. It counts orders with a 1- or 2-star seller review, an A-to-z Guarantee claim or a credit card chargeback over a 60-day period. The cancellation rate must stay under 2.5% over 7 days, the late shipment rate under 4%, and the valid tracking rate above 95%. Missing a target can lead to suspension of Fulfilled by Merchant selling privileges or deactivation of seller-fulfilled offers.

Our inference: because these four metrics apply only to seller-fulfilled orders, using FBA removes most of that exposure, in exchange for its fees.

eBay's seller standards policy grades every seller as Below Standard, Above Standard or Top Rated on the 20th of each month. Staying Above Standard in the US means a transaction defect rate of no more than 2% and no more than 2 cases, or 0.3% of transactions, closed without your resolution. A Below Standard seller may be placed lower in search, is blocked from Promoted Listings and pays an extra 6% on final value fees.

Sales tax and tax forms

Both marketplaces collect sales tax from the buyer and remit it where marketplace facilitator laws require; eBay says this needs no action from the seller and carries no charge. The fee treatment differs. Amazon's referral fee excludes the tax it collects. eBay's final value fee is charged on a total that includes it, so $8 of sales tax on a $100 order lowers your eBay payout by $1.09.

Each company describes the same federal Form 1099-K threshold, more than $20,000 and more than 200 transactions, and each notes that some states set a lower one. Amazon requires every seller to complete its tax information interview. 1099-K for resellers explains the form.

Amazon or eBay: which should you use?

Start from the inventory. This site has no sell-through data for Amazon or eBay, so the list below is about rules and costs and not about where an item sells sooner.

  • A used one-off item: eBay. You write the listing and show the actual item. On Amazon the item needs a matching product page, a category that allows used condition and no brand restriction.
  • New items with barcodes, bought in quantity: Amazon is open if Seller Central shows “Sell this product”. Keep the purchase invoices. From 41 sales a month the Professional plan costs less than $0.99 per item. eBay takes the same stock with no plan fee.
  • Books and media: books need no category approval on Amazon and can be sold used; music and DVDs need approval. A $15 book leaves $9.96 on Amazon Individual and $12.30 on eBay, before shipping.
  • Branded clothing: Amazon's category table allows used apparel, but a brand can carry its own restriction, and clothing over $20 pays a 17% referral fee. A $40 piece leaves $32.21 on Amazon Individual and $34.16 on eBay.
  • A product you make yourself: eBay accepts it as an ordinary listing. Amazon needs a product ID or an exemption; makers should read Etsy vs Amazon Handmade and Etsy vs eBay.
  • Collectibles: eBay offers auction-style listings and charges 13.25% on trading cards, comics and coins. On Amazon, collectible coins, entertainment collectibles and sports memorabilia all require approval, and a Collectible listing must describe what gives the item added value.

If an item qualifies on both, compare the payout for your category and price in the Amazon fee calculator and the eBay fee calculator.

Seller Knowledge Base

Amazon vs eBay: seller questions

What you can list, plans, fees, payouts and returns.

Is Amazon or eBay better for selling?

It depends on the item. Amazon is built around a product catalog: you add an offer to an existing product page, most categories need a product ID such as a UPC, and some categories, brands and products need approval. eBay lets you write your own listing for almost any item, used or new. For a used one-off item eBay is the simpler fit. On fees, a $100 sale in a standard category leaves $86.00 on eBay and $84.01 on Amazon’s Individual plan, before shipping and item cost.

Is it cheaper to sell on Amazon or eBay?

In a standard category eBay takes a little less. eBay charges 13.6% plus $0.40 per order in most categories. Amazon charges a 15% referral fee in many categories, plus $0.99 per item on the Individual plan or $39.99 a month on the Professional plan. On a $50 sale you keep $42.80 on eBay, $41.51 on Amazon Individual and $42.50 on Amazon Professional before the monthly fee. Fulfillment by Amazon fees are extra.

Can you sell used items on Amazon?

In some categories. Amazon’s category table allows used items in apparel, shoes, books, consumer electronics, video games and home, among others. It lists toys, beauty, baby products other than apparel, and grocery as new only. Used items are graded Like New, Very Good, Good or Acceptable, and an item that is not clean, needs repair or is missing essential parts can’t be listed.

Do I need a Professional plan to sell on Amazon?

No. The Individual plan has no monthly fee and costs $0.99 for each item sold. The Professional plan costs $39.99 a month with no per-item fee, so it is cheaper from 41 sales a month. Advertising, bulk listing tools and setting your own shipping rates need the Professional plan. As of September 2026, Amazon says offers from all sellers are eligible to be evaluated for the Featured Offer.

Do I need a UPC to sell on Amazon?

For most categories, yes, when you create a new product page or offer. Amazon requires an industry-standard product ID such as a UPC, EAN or ISBN and checks IDs against the GS1 database. If your product has no ID, you can request an exemption.

Which pays sellers faster, Amazon or eBay?

eBay generally makes funds available within about 2 days of confirming the buyer’s payment, unless they are on hold, and a bank generally takes 1–3 business days after a payout is sent. Amazon’s standard policy reserves the funds from each order until 7 days after delivery, pays out on a 14-day cycle, and says a transfer can take up to five business days to reach your bank.

How do returns differ on Amazon and eBay?

On eBay you choose a return policy, including no returns, but the eBay Money Back Guarantee still lets a buyer return an item that doesn’t match the listing within 30 days of delivery, and you pay that return shipping. On Amazon, sellers who ship their own orders must follow Amazon’s return policy, which allows most items to be returned within 30 days. Starting December 18, 2026, those returns must include a prepaid return label. With Fulfillment by Amazon, Amazon handles returns.

Official sources & updates

These US sources were checked November 12, 2026. Examples are estimates, not settlement statements. Check your order for promotions, label charges, and seller-specific deductions. Canadian rates are outside this guide.